Worst Ideas the Erins have done in Warriors

If you think the Erins made a really bad idea in any book of the series, feel free to share it here. Please add a spoiler warning including the series name above your post.

Excluding Hollyleaf from the three, not giving her a power, and killing her off

 * (Omen of the Stars Spoilers)

To me, this was the most dumb idea the Erins have done in the series. I only liked Hollyleaf because I have an interest in she-cats more that toms and she’s the only she—cat in her litter. I developed a liking to her, and a hate to Lionblaze because he’s a gary stu. It would have been fine if Dovewing kept her power, but why can’t Hollyleaf be the fourth cat and have speed or something among those lines? And why Firestar, for the millionth time, is the cat for a prophecy? And why did they kill her off when she could have just survived further in the books and gotten respect and a living mate and kits? -Dew

Reviving Tigerheart

 * (A vision of shadows spoilers)

I honestly hate this decision too. Tigerheart was brave, and gave his life to save Hollowkit from that owl. He deserved to join his ancestors, but they were like ‘whatever give him his lives’. That’s just dumb. Tigerheart was a dumb cat who didn’t deserve to be leader; Tawnypelt did. And resurrecting him shouldn’t have even been planned. He caused the SkyClan conflict and wanted to drive them out again. Why can’t they resurrect cats that need to be resurrected, such as Hollyleaf, Honeyfern, Hazeltail, Icecloud, Seedpaw, Ashfur, Feathertail etc. -Dew